ADC leadership crisis: How an earlier court ruling differed from the latest judgment

A Federal High Court ruling in July 2026 had dismissed a challenge to the emergence of David Mark and Rauf Aregbesola as leaders of the African Democratic Congress, citing lack of jurisdiction to intervene in the party’s internal affairs.

The decision has come under renewed attention following a separate judgment delivered by another judge of the same court in Abuja on Thursday, November 5, which nullified the Mark-led leadership and decisions taken under it, including the nomination of former Vice-President Atiku Abubakar as the party’s presidential candidate for the 2027 election.

The latest case was instituted by Nafiu Bala, a former national deputy chairman of the ADC in the North-East, who questioned the process through which Mark and other members of the party’s caretaker committee assumed leadership after the resignation of former national chairman, Ralph Nwosu.

Presiding judge, Justice Peter Lifu, upheld Bala’s claims and invalidated decisions made by the leadership under Mark, creating uncertainty over the party’s preparations for the next general election.

Bala had asked the court to set aside the decisions of the caretaker leadership and stop Mark and Aregbesola from presenting themselves as the party’s national chairman and national secretary, respectively.

However, the latest ruling followed an earlier legal challenge brought by Leke Abejide, a member of the House of Representatives, who had also questioned the legitimacy of the party’s leadership transition.

Abejide’s challenge to Mark’s emergence

In February 2026, Abejide approached the Federal High Court in Abuja, seeking to invalidate the transfer of the ADC’s leadership from Nwosu to Mark and Aregbesola.

The lawmaker asked the court to declare the handover, which took place on July 2, 2025, at the Shehu Musa Yar’Adua Centre in Abuja, “illegal, unlawful, null and void”.

He also sought an order permanently restraining the two politicians from parading themselves as the party’s national leaders.

But on July 2, 2026, Justice Musa Liman dismissed the case after upholding preliminary objections filed by the ADC, Nwosu, Mark and Aregbesola.

The defendants had challenged the court’s authority to hear the matter, arguing that it concerned the internal affairs of a political party.

Why the July suit was dismissed

In his ruling, Liman held that the court lacked jurisdiction to intervene in the ADC’s internal affairs and described the case as non-justiciable.

He also found that Abejide had not established the legal standing required to institute the action because he failed to demonstrate how the emergence of the Mark-led leadership violated his rights.

The judge further ruled that Nwosu’s transfer of the party’s leadership to Mark did not breach the provisions of the ADC constitution.

Following the dismissal, the court ordered Abejide to pay N2m to each of the defendants as costs and imposed a separate N10m fine on his lawyer.

Political developments after the ruling

Before leaving the ADC, Abejide and Bala were among those who opposed the leadership arrangement that brought Mark and Aregbesola into the party’s top positions.

However, Abejide defected from the ADC to the ruling All Progressives Congress in May 2026, months before the latest judgment.

The two cases therefore produced different outcomes despite addressing challenges to the same leadership arrangement: Liman dismissed Abejide’s suit on jurisdictional and legal-standing grounds, while Lifu upheld Bala’s claims and nullified the decisions of the Mark-led leadership.

 

The latest judgment could have consequences for the ADC’s participation in the 2027 elections, particularly its presidential nomination, although the party’s next steps will be important in determining how the dispute unfolds.

Share This Article
Leave a Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Exit mobile version